Understanding How Philadelphia Medical Malpractice Intersects With HIPAA Violation, And How Lawyers And Healthcare Providers Protect Your Privacy And Claims
- Dave Hoover
- 4 days ago
- 13 min read
Key Takeaways
This article explains how Philadelphia medical malpractice and HIPAA violations can overlap and support legal claims.
Learn what the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) requires and what constitutes a Pennsylvania HIPAA violation.
Understand how a Philadelphia HIPAA violation can affect victims and when you have legal grounds for a Pennsylvania medical malpractice case.
Discover how Philadelphia medical malpractice attorneys protect your rights and privacy.
What Does HIPAA Mean? What Does HIP Mean?
The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) is a federal law that establishes national standards to protect sensitive patient health information. Enacted in 1996, HIPAA was designed to ensure that individuals maintain control over their medical records and personal health data while allowing the healthcare system to function efficiently and securely. HIPAA limits how healthcare providers, insurers, and related entities use, disclose, store, and transmit your Protected Health Information (PHI).
HIPAA is needed because medical records contain some of the most personal and sensitive details about a person’s life—diagnoses, surgeries, medications, mental health treatment, reproductive history, genetic data, and financial information tied to insurance coverage. Without strict legal protections, this information could be misused, disclosed without consent, or exposed to identity theft and discrimination. HIPAA creates safeguards not only to protect patients, but also to guide healthcare entities in building secure systems, training staff, and maintaining professional standards.
Importantly, HIPAA applies at every stage of healthcare delivery. Whether a patient is being transported in an ambulance, treated in an emergency room, undergoing surgery in an operating room, or receiving routine care in a clinic, HIPAA protections remain in place. The law applies regardless of whether the healthcare provider is a midwife, nurse, physician, technician, therapist, or administrative staff member. It also applies to hospitals and healthcare systems as entire entities—especially when systemic failures in data security, staff training, or oversight place patient information at risk. From bedside conversations to electronic record systems, HIPAA governs how information must be handled.
What Is Philadelphia Medical Malpractice?
At the same time, Philadelphia medical malpractice is a separate but equally serious legal concept. Medical malpractice occurs when a healthcare professional or entity fails to meet the accepted standard of care in their field, resulting in injury or harm to a patient. This failure can happen at many stages and in many places within the healthcare system—during diagnosis, surgery, childbirth, medication administration, follow-up care, or even during discharge planning. Pennsylvania medical malpractice may involve doctors, nurses, specialists, anesthesiologists, technicians, or the hospital itself. In many cases, more than one party may share liability for a single medical error, especially when multiple breakdowns occur in communication, supervision, or policy enforcement.
Healthcare is complex, and medical errors often result from a combination of individual mistakes and systemic issues. For example, a surgical error might involve not only a physician’s action but also inadequate hospital protocols, faulty equipment, poor documentation, or lack of informed consent. Because so many factors can contribute to patient harm, identifying all liable parties is an essential part of pursuing justice.
When malpractice happens, injured patients may bring a Philadelphia medical malpractice lawsuit to seek compensation.
To file a successful Pennsylvania medical malpractice case, you typically must prove:
A valid doctor-patient relationship existed.
The healthcare provider acted negligently or breached the standard of care.
That breach directly caused your injury.
You suffered measurable harm or damages.
An important part of this process can involve violations of your privacy rights under HIPAA—especially if a breach of your confidentiality contributed to harm or loss.
What Is a HIPAA Violation?
A Philadelphia HIPAA violation occurs when a covered entity (like a doctor’s office, hospital, or insurer) improperly accesses, discloses, or fails to protect your PHI. HIPAA applies to all forms of communication—electronic, paper, or oral—and protects all medical details that could reasonably identify you.
Common causes of HIPAA violations include unauthorized disclosures, weak security measures, theft, hacking, poorly trained staff, and improper disposal of records.
When PHI is disclosed without consent, or when a healthcare provider fails to safeguard your data, this can lead to not only regulatory penalties but also legal claims in the context of Philadelphia medical malpractice and Pennsylvania HIPAA violation lawsuits.
How Could HIPAA Be Violated?
HIPAA violations can occur in many different ways, and they often happen more easily than patients realize. A Philadelphia HIPAA violation may involve a single careless employee, a systemic failure within a hospital, or even a large-scale cybersecurity breach affecting thousands of patients. Because HIPAA protects some of the most sensitive information a person has, even a small lapse can create serious consequences.
For example, a nurse, midwife, or other staff member may post photos of patients—including newborns—on social media without consent. Even if the post seems harmless or celebratory, it can expose identifiable Protected Health Information (PHI), such as faces, names, dates of birth, or hospital details. This kind of disclosure is a clear violation of HIPAA and can cause emotional distress and humiliation for families who expected complete privacy during medical care.
How Do You Know Who Is Responsible for a HIPAA Violation?
HIPAA breaches also happen through technology failures. Healthcare systems may suffer cyberattacks, ransomware incidents, or unauthorized access to electronic medical records. When hospitals fail to encrypt data or maintain strong cybersecurity protections, hackers can steal patient information and sell it, exploit it, or use it for identity theft. These incidents show that HIPAA compliance is not only about doctors and nurses—it also depends heavily on IT staff and institutional safeguards.
Another common violation occurs when staff members access patient records without a legitimate medical reason. Sometimes employees look up records out of curiosity, gossip, or personal interest. Even if no information is shared outside the hospital, unauthorized access itself can violate HIPAA because patients have the right to control who sees their private medical history.
Some of the most common causes of HIPAA violations are:
Poorly Trained Employees
Gossiping
Improper Disposal of Records
Unencrypted Data/Hacking
Theft of Devices
Generally Poor Security
Under HIPAA, healthcare providers must properly train employees, enforce privacy policies, and secure patient data to prevent sensitive medical information from becoming public.
What Could Happen With Your Wrongfully Disclosed Personal Information?
Importantly, HIPAA can be breached at many levels of healthcare delivery—from frontline medical employees, to administrative staff, to IT departments, and even the hospital itself as an entity with systemic security failures. Sometimes the problem is not one person’s mistake, but an institutional pattern of poor oversight, weak cybersecurity, or lack of compliance protocols.
When such breaches happen, victims may face identity theft, discrimination, financial harm, emotional distress, and a lasting loss of trust in their healthcare providers. In some situations, a HIPAA violation may also become grounds to file a lawsuit against the healthcare entity, especially when the breach causes real harm, exposes private data, or reflects broader negligence in protecting patients.
In cases where improper disclosure or breach of privacy contributed to harm, your Philadelphia medical malpractice lawsuit may include claims related to both negligence in care and violation of privacy rights, and an experienced legal team can determine whether the HIPAA breach strengthens your case against the responsible provider or institution.
Is HIPAA Violation a Medical Malpractice?
HIPAA protects a patient’s right to privacy, not the right to receive a certain medical standard of care. For that reason, HIPAA violations do not typically qualify as medical malpractice on their own. However, a privacy breach may still be part of a broader pattern of substandard care within a healthcare entity. In some situations, a HIPAA violation can be included in a medical malpractice lawsuit alongside other breached duties, such as failing to obtain informed consent for medical procedures, including surgeries. When multiple obligations are violated, the overall conduct may contribute to patient harm and reflect negligence in the way care is provided. If you are uncertain about your rights, speaking with an attorney can help you understand the best path forward.
If you or a loved one may be a victim of Philadelphia stroke misdiagnosis, cancer misdiagnosis, birth injury, or other substandard medical care, discuss your case with our trusted lawyers—who will never disclose your information to anyone—by calling 267-490-3988.
Our Recently Published Article Illustrates Privacy Violation and Medical Malpractice in a Devastating, Real-Life Birth Injury Case
We recently published an in-depth article examining a profoundly heartbreaking Pennsylvania case where a privacy violation and medical malpractice tragically intersected in the life of a newborn and her parents. The case, which concluded in June 2025 with a $5.6 million jury verdict, involved catastrophic birth injuries and a deeply troubling breach of patient confidentiality. We are deeply sorry for what this family has endured, and we share this case with the utmost respect for the parents and the child whose lives were forever changed.
The lawsuit was filed in 2020 by the parents of a baby girl against the delivering midwife and a Philadelphia-based hospital. During labor, critical fetal positioning abnormalities were allegedly not recognized or properly addressed. As a result, the baby suffered severe brain damage and permanent vision impairment. The jury ultimately found that negligent monitoring and failures in care during delivery contributed to these devastating injuries—injuries that will require lifelong medical support and specialized care.
A Double Tragedy: Birth Injury Followed by a Breach of the Parents’ Privacy
For the parents, the suffering did not end with the birth injury. While they were coping with the shock and grief of learning about their child’s permanent medical condition, they were also confronted with the painful reality that their newborn’s image and private medical details had been shared publicly without their consent. What should have been a confidential and protected medical environment became a source of additional trauma. The breach of privacy compounded their emotional distress, intensifying feelings of vulnerability, betrayal, and loss of trust. At a time when families most need compassion and discretion, the disclosure of private information can deepen the wound and prolong the healing process.
Compounding the tragedy, the midwife reportedly posted a photo of the newborn on her personal social media account, along with private medical details, without the parents’ consent. This act exposed sensitive patient information and intensified the parents’ emotional trauma during an already fragile and painful time. The jury found liability not only for medical negligence but also for invasion of privacy and breach of confidentiality.
This case serves as a powerful real-life example of how medical malpractice—specifically birth injury—and violations of patient privacy can overlap. It also underscores how posting medical information or images on social media, even if done casually or without malicious intent, can result in serious legal accountability. Healthcare professionals are entrusted with both the physical safety and the privacy of their patients, and when either duty is breached, the consequences can be life-altering.
We approach this subject gently and respectfully, recognizing that behind every verdict is a family that has suffered immeasurable loss. Our thoughts remain with the parents and child affected by this case, and our commitment continues to be advocating for accountability, privacy, and justice for families facing similar circumstances.
How Do You Know If HIPAA Was Violated?
Our Pennsylvania medical malpractice attorneys will carefully review the facts, your medical records, communication logs, and any unauthorized disclosures to confirm whether a Philadelphia HIPAA violation occurred. We assess whether your files were improperly accessed, shared, hacked, or otherwise mishandled without consent.
Do Philadelphia Medical Malpractice Lawyers Have to Follow HIPAA?
HIPAA primarily applies to healthcare providers, health plans, and healthcare clearinghouses—not to law firms in the same way it governs hospitals or medical offices. However, that does not mean your medical information is unprotected when you speak to a lawyer. Instead of HIPAA, attorneys are bound by strict rules of attorney-client privilege and professional confidentiality, which often provide even broader protections for your personal and medical information.
When you work with our Pennsylvania medical malpractice attorneys, your privacy and trust are paramount. Attorney-client privilege means that any information you share with us—including your Protected Health Information (PHI), medical records, diagnoses, treatment history, and personal details—cannot be disclosed to anyone without your express permission. This protection applies to conversations, emails, documents, and all communications related to your case.
We implement secure systems and internal safeguards to ensure that your records remain confidential and protected throughout the legal process.
Is HIPAA the Same Thing as an NDA?
No—HIPAA and a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) are not the same. HIPAA is a federal law governing how covered entities must protect health information. An NDA is a contract between parties to keep specified information confidential.
HIPAA applies broadly and has legal enforcement by government agencies. An NDA is a private agreement enforceable in court between the signatories.
Is Attorney-Client Privilege the Same as an NDA?
Attorney-client privilege is a legal protection ensuring communications between you and your lawyer remain confidential and cannot be disclosed without your consent. While similar to an NDA in protecting information, attorney-client privilege is a recognized legal privilege that applies automatically in legal contexts—it doesn’t require a separate contract like an NDA.
What Are the Consequences of a Client–Attorney Privilege Violation?
We do not—and will never—disclose your personal PHI or any other sensitive data to outside parties without your authorization or unless required by law as part of properly pursuing your claim. A breach of attorney-client privilege or unauthorized release of confidential files could result in severe legal and professional consequences for a lawyer, including disciplinary action by the state bar, loss of license, financial penalties, and permanent reputational damage.
Improper disclosure by a law firm could also seriously harm your case. Defense attorneys could attempt to use exposed information to undermine your credibility. Insurance companies representing liable healthcare providers might try to reduce or deny compensation based on disclosed medical history. Marketing agencies or third parties could exploit private health details. In extreme cases, insurers might attempt to raise premiums or deny certain coverage if sensitive health risks become known.
Unlike careless disclosures that sometimes occur in healthcare settings, our Pennsylvania medical malpractice lawyers are ethically and legally obligated to maintain full confidentiality. Protecting your information is not just a policy—it is a professional duty central to our role as your legal advocates.
What Are the Consequences for Patients After Their PHI Disclosure?
Healthcare providers in Pennsylvania are legally required to keep your medical records confidential, secure, and protected from improper access. When they fail to do so—whether through negligence, weak cybersecurity, poor employee training, or even intentional misconduct—the consequences can be severe not only for the healthcare entity, but especially for the patient whose private information was exposed.
A HIPAA breach is not just a technical mistake. For patients, it can create very real and lasting harm. Once sensitive medical details are disclosed, victims may face identity theft, financial fraud, or unauthorized use of insurance information.
The disclosure of Protected Health Information (PHI) can affect nearly every part of a patient’s life. Patients may suffer discrimination in the workplace or fear that employers may learn about serious diagnoses, mental health treatment, substance use history, or other deeply personal conditions. A breach can also cause emotional distress, anxiety, embarrassment, and a loss of trust in the healthcare system—particularly when the information involves reproductive health, sexually transmitted infections, cancer diagnoses, or other highly private matters.
Unauthorized access to PHI could expose sensitive details to hackers, insurers, defense attorneys, employers, marketing firms, or other third parties who should never see or use that information. Patients may find themselves targeted by scams, aggressive advertising, or unfair insurance practices, such as increased premiums or denial of coverage after hidden health risks become known. Even personal relationships can be affected if confidential information becomes public in a community or on social media.
Why Healthcare Providers Must Protect Your Data and the Consequences if They Don’t
For healthcare providers, HIPAA violations can result in major regulatory penalties. Federal fines may range from thousands to millions of dollars, and repeated or willful violations can lead to criminal charges, loss of licensing, and serious reputational damage. Civil lawsuits may also result in significant compensation for victims when the breach causes measurable harm.
Ultimately, protecting patient privacy is not optional—it is a fundamental obligation of safe, professional healthcare. When providers fail to uphold it, the consequences can extend far beyond paperwork, impacting a patient’s finances, dignity, mental well-being, and future security.
If you have any concerns about your medical data privacy or the standard of care provided by your healthcare provider, call us today at 267-490-3988 for a confidential case review.
What May Protected Health Information (PHI) Include?
Protected Health Information (PHI) includes far more than just a patient’s name or a doctor’s note. Medical records are often extensive, highly detailed files that healthcare providers rely on to deliver treatment, coordinate care, document procedures, and comply with legal and insurance requirements. Because these records contain deeply personal information, HIPAA strictly limits how they may be accessed, stored, or shared.
Protected Health Information may include a wide range of identifying, medical, clinical, financial, and visual records connected to your care, such as:
Identifying details such as your full name, address, phone number, date of birth, Social Security number, and medical record number
Medical diagnoses
Physician observations and clinical notes
Treatment plans
Surgical notes (including intraoperative documentation)
Prescriptions and medication history
Allergy history
Mental health records (including therapy notes and psychiatric evaluations)
Physical therapy documentation
Laboratory test results (bloodwork, pathology reports, etc.)
Imaging studies such as X-rays, CT scans, or MRIs (including radiology reports)
Genetic testing data
Billing and payment information
Insurance claims and coverage details
Referral records between providers
Discharge summaries (particularly following hospital stays)
Communications between healthcare providers about your condition (including electronic health record entries)
Photographs or digital images of your body—such as injury photos, newborn delivery images, or surgical documentation (especially in hospital settings)
Why Do Doctors Need Such Personal Details About Their Patients?
Healthcare providers maintain these records because they are essential for safe and continuous care, but they are also required by law to store them for specific periods of time. In Pennsylvania, medical records are typically retained for several years, and in some cases much longer, depending on the type of treatment and whether the patient was a minor. After retention periods expire, providers must properly destroy or archive records securely, ensuring that patient information is not exposed through careless disposal.
Access to these files is strictly limited. Only authorized individuals—such as treating physicians, nurses involved in care, billing departments, or legally permitted entities like certain insurers—may view PHI, and only when necessary for legitimate healthcare operations. Unauthorized access by employees, third parties, or hackers is a serious HIPAA violation.
Improper disclosure of these details can lead to profound personal, emotional, and financial harm, including identity theft, discrimination, embarrassment, and misuse of sensitive health information by parties who should never have access to it.
Social Media and HIPAA: A Cautionary Note
Healthcare workers and even patients sometimes share medical photos or details online. A documented case involved a nurse posting images of a neonatal patient on social media without consent, resulting in a disciplinary investigation and termination.
If you share your own medical details online, you should be aware that even "private" posts may be seen by unintended audiences. Once your information is on the internet, deleting it doesn’t guarantee complete removal. For your safety and privacy, avoid posting PHI online—even if you think it’s “just for friends.”
Our Philadelphia medical malpractice attorneys strongly encourage you to protect your privacy and contact us before sharing any medical records publicly.
Contact Us for a Confidential Review
If you believe you are a victim of a HIPAA violation or have suffered harm from medical negligence, Philadelphia stroke misdiagnosis, cancer misdiagnosis, birth injury, contact our experienced Pennsylvania medical malpractice lawyers. We will review your case, confirm any HIPAA breach, and discuss your legal rights—no obligation, complete confidentiality. Additionally, your case will be handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless and until we are able to recover compensation for your damages.
Your privacy and comfort are our priorities. Call us at (267) 490 - 3988 for a confidential consultation and immediate assistance.
Comments